Archive for May, 2011
Case study: Facebook ads create Hollywood buzz
May 13th
I’d like to welcome Robert Dempsey as the newest {grow} contributing columnist. Here is an amazing story as his first post!
A brand new indie movie is being released in Los Angeles in one week. The goal is to tell as many locals as possible – online – and fill that theater. What do you do?
This is a true story of a movie industry client that came to Gunner Technology – a company I work with – that had one week to get as much exposure for an upcoming movie launch as possible.
Here’s what happened.
The movie is a comedy called Meeting Spencer starting Jeffery Tambor and Melissa McGraw. In this case study, we focused on launching a week-long Facebook ad campaign that delivered some stunning results that ultimately grew visits to the client’s website by more than 150% per day, garnered more than 400 views of their movie preview, grew Facebook page likes by more than 200% … and filled the theater.
A Star is Born
Here are the tactics of the campaign:
- Uploaded the latest and best version of the movie preview to YouTube, and optimized it for the movie and the names of the actors
- Complete overhaul of the movie website, including new graphics, embedding the YouTube movie preview on the homepage, putting the best movie reviews under the preview, and adding a call to action below that. Basically this was a single page designed to show off the movie and get people to the theater.
- Added a splash graphic with the movie location and show times to the home tab of the Facebook page (using the Involver app).
- Created a highly targeted Facebook campaign for people in and around LA that liked everything — and I mean everything — to do with all of the main actors
- Every 18-24 hours we updated all of the Facebook ads based on what was getting the clicks.
Let’s look at the specific results delivered, and the lessons learned from the week.
Campaign Stats
The entire campaign was from Sunday, April 17 to Sunday, April 24. Here’s the complete rundown of the results:
- 1,194 page views on the website (after a complete makeover)
- 452 YouTube video views
- 766 clicks on Facebook ads
- 130 more Facebook page likes
- People in seats.
Not too shabby for a single week.
3 Lessons From The Campaign
Lesson #1 – Facebook Ads Have The Lifespan Of A Mosquito
The biggest lesson overall is that the lifespan of a typical Facebook ad is 24 hours. This means you need to be A/B testing ads continuously and ruthlessly killing off the ones that aren’t getting the clicks. The more clicks you get the lower your cost per click (CPC). In our case the average CPC was $0.50. That, in a word, is awesome for anything pay per click.
Lesson #2 – Have A Splash Page
Ironically I have no splash page for my Facebook pages, but I always create one for my client. In this case, while not a goal of the campaign, we increased Page likes by 212%. Not too shabby for something we weren’t even going for. We used Involver to quickly upload our splash page graphic. Took about 5 minutes.
Lesson #3 – When At First You Don’t Succeed
When creating the ads for your campaign and selecting the targeting options, the automatic drop-downs that Facebook provides don’t always work. If this happens, log out and come back in an hour or two. I tried three different web browsers and none of them worked; I waited an hour, came back, and was able to create the campaign.
What Have You Found?
Have you use Facebook ads for PR or to send people to your website? Any additional lessons you can share?
Let us know in the comments below.
I’ll see you there!
Robert Dempsey is the Itinerant Entrepreneur. He combines technology, psychology, and marketing to help his clients build their empires using strategic marketing. You can find him at http://BuildMeAnEmpire.com
When did we forget about strategy?
May 12th
Does anybody on the digital media scene pay attention to strategy? Or, are we so determined to lead our clients into social media nirvana that we dance right over that little detail?
Joseph Jaffe, a regular on Mitch Joel’s wonderful Six Pixels podcast series, recently provided a passionate argument for his point that digital agencies seem to have abandoned the idea of strategy. He would know. He recently served as a judge for a national digital strategy competition and said it was an exercise in picking the least bad submission. “There was nothing there,” he said. “No strategy. No meat on the bones at all.”
This reflects my experience with many clients too. Somehow we got caught up in plastering the world with Facebook pages and lost sight of the true purpose of our business: Create shareholder value through a differentiated — and truly strategic — business proposition.
- Cut costs?
- More advertising?
- Work longer hours?
- Create a Twitter account?
All of these tactics might provide short-term gains … but they’re not really strategic. You can’t cut your way to success or even tweet your way to success and your competitors are probably trying to do the same thing, aren’t they? So if they are, how is this going to create ADVANTAGE for YOU?
There is only one way to create competitive advantage in the long-term:
Listen to your customers more effectively and respond more rapidly than your competitors.
That’s it.
I’ve just saved you a ton of money on business books and consultants because every successful business strategy is based on this idea. Every great product innovation has this concept at its foundation.
And it is a continuous process! Don’t ever assume you know what’s going on with your customers with the speed that the market can shift. Embrace your customers. Keep listening! Keep responding! Keep innovating! That is the core of strategy.
What has your experience been? Is your company really focused on strategy or quick fixes?
When it comes to social media, stop trying to “work the room”
May 11th
By Contributing {grow} Columnist Srinivas Rao
When I look at social media I don’t see a way to lower your cost of marketing, increase ROI, or grow your brand. What I see is access to a global networking of inspiring people.
You see, the benefits of blogging, tweeting, and social media extend far beyond the walls of your business and the depths of your pockets. When you take the approach of making friends instead of followers, the world opens up to you in a way that you never imagined possible.
A few weeks ago, I sold everything I owned and left the U.S. to move to Costa Rica with some pairs of shorts, t-shirts, a surfboard, a laptop and a camera. That’s it. I think you’ll see why concentrating on “friends” instead of “followers” has helped my journey in immeasurable ways:
A Couch to Sleep On
I recently had a chat with John Falchetto, one of my favorite new bloggers on the rise. It’s coincidental that I found an expat life coach just in time for my relocation to Costa Rica. In my chat with John he told me something that really struck me. He talked about the importance of connecting with people who are not your clients. I’m not one of John’s clients and he’s not one of mine. So you might be thinking, why connect? Because we’re interested in each other as people.
I’ve been struggling to figure out where I’m to stay during Blogworld since I’ll be in New York City for 10 days and I’m on a tight budget. A few days ago John offered me a pull-out couch in his room. So now I have a place to sleep. But I didn’t connect with John because he had a couch for me. It was because I like his story and I think what he’s up to is interesting.
A Second Family
Adjusting to life in another country can be a challenge. For me the whole expat experience has had its share of ups and downs and there are days when I feel like living the dream is more like living a nightmare. Fortunately, I’ve had somebody like Mark Harai to help ease my transition to my new life. If you spend even a few days at his house, you’ll quickly find yourself with a second family. There’s never a dull moment in his household with four kids, and his wife will make sure you are well fed. How did I find my second family? It all started because of our conversations on Twitter. What’s even more interesting is that it has actually resulted in us doing business together even though it was not our original intention.
A Suit for Blogworld
When I found I’d be speaking at Blogworld, I realized I didn’t have a suit. Just shorts, remember? When I wrote about this in a recent post, Dino Dogan offered to send me a suit so that I wouldn’t have to buy one and bring one back to Costa Rica. I don’t know how, or if, we’ll ever do business together and neither does he. But you can be sure that when I have the opportunity to return such a favor, I’ll do it no questions asked.
Conversation for Sake of Conversation
When I recently spoke with Dino, he told me one of the smartest things I’ve ever heard. He said the key to success on the social web is to completely eliminate self interest.
It seems counter-intuitive that in the process of trying to grow your blog or brand that you would eliminate self interest. But based on my experience it seems to work quite well. We get caught up in metrics, measurements, ROI, and more that we often forget about conversation for the sake of conversation. I’ll go so far as to argue that some of the greatest value is created through casual conversations.
This is where trust is created, relationships are built, and friendships are formed. It’s never about what you can get. It’s about what you can give.
The human ability to detect insincerity is amplified on the social web. When we stop trying to “work the room,” we tend to get the world handed us on a silver platter. What’s been your experience?
Srinivas Rao is a contributing writer to {grow}. You can read more of his original writing at The Skool of Life blog or listen to his podcast at BlogcastFM. Follow him on Twitter at @skooloflife
Connecting Social Media Marketing with Buyer Behavior
May 10th
In 2010 The Base One Agency of London sponsored some of the most important research I’ve seen in our field. And they have followed it up with another great report for 2011! Their Buyersphere Report provided statistically-valid data connecting inbound marketing activities with buyer behavior.
In a social media world filled with questionable research and lightweight infographics, this is research we can really use. I’m proud to be able to provide an advance summary of this report to the {grow} community.
Here is the report summary of data from more than 1,000 European B2B purchasing agents. What are your main take-aways from this research?
The dominance of ‘traditional’ online
Despite the rising popularity of social media, “traditional online” channels of supplier websites, search and emails are those most used by buyers.
68% of buyers said they consulted supplier websites, while 65% used search engines to find the information they needed to support their purchase decision. The use of social media channels such as Twitter, LinkedIn, blogs and Facebook all grew (Facebook, in fact, doubled in popularity from 2010 to 2011) but they are still much less frequently used than the ‘traditional online’ methods. Of course, this does not prove that social media is on the wane. A Google search frequently leads to a link provided by a social media network even if the buyer does not start there.
The youth factor
Splitting the data between under-30s and over-30s shows the inevitable tendency of younger buyers to use the newer channels — the under-30s were three times more likely to use blogs to help them select suppliers, for example — suggesting that social media usage will only increase as one generation gradually succeeds the other. But in the short term, it would appear that investing in SEO and websites should still command the lion’s share of the marketing budget.
A growing hunger for information
Comparing results from last year shows a significant growth in the number of information channels used by buyers. This is a clear sign that we are moving from the traditional outbound marketing model [where we used to broadcast information in the hope that some of it would stick] to an inbound model [where buyers choose what information they need and go and find it themselves online]. This means that there is a greater appetite for information – and therefore a greater burden on the brands to create more content of all kinds, in order to satisfy this hunger. It is clear that companies with a structured, considered programme for creating whitepapers, videos, blogs and the like are going to be the ones more likely to appear on buyers’ radar as they do their online research.
Are webinars coming of age?
One of the most dramatic change in behaviour will interest marketers who run their own events, because we have seen the proportion of buyers who used offline events when seeking purchase information fall dramatically. Last year, one in three buyers attended an event as part of their information gathering; in 2011 that proportion had almost halved to just 18%. This was accompanied by – although not necessarily caused by – an equally marked rise in the use of online events or webinars. One in ten buyers used this channel last year; in 2011 that rose to 27%, almost a threefold increase
There could be many reasons. But it is reasonable to assume that buyers are getting more used to webinars and that brands are creating many more of them. But perhaps the most interesting observation is that this is a classic case of digitisation; of digital technology creating a version of something that is utterly distinct from its offline counterpart.
But this is only part of the picture. In terms of influence, webinars do not come close to real events, which were rated as the most influential information source across all buying stages with 46% of buyers giveng them a rating of 9 or 10 for influence.
A two-tier Europe?
One of the improvements of this year’s Buyersphere Report was to include and compare the responses of 500 business buyers in France, Germany, Benelux and Italy. B2B brands are increasingly operating on a pan-European basis and we need to understand cultural and behavioural differences.
These differences emerged most strongly when we looked at the social media information sources used. In Germany and the UK, 48% and 46% of buyers respectively used social media tools during the buying process; this compared to just 22%, 26% and 35% of French, Benelux and Italian respondents. The use of traditional online, by contrast, was consistent across all five, varying only between 88% and 93%. In the UK, 16% of buyers used Facebook at some point in their research, compared with only 5% of Benelux buyers.
Attitudes to sharing
Another fascinating insight was the attitudes towards forwarding information. While tools like Twitter and Facebook are very efficient at quickly spreading information through friend networks, they are not the preferred options. Only 9% said they used Facebook “very often” to share professional information, whilst 27% used the company intranet and 44% used email with the same level of frequency.
But how willing are users to share their own data? Marketers often agonise over whether to allow their content to spread freely or to use it to generate leads by insisting on a data capture form. The Report suggests we should tread carefully, with 55% of buyers discouraged ‘very’ or ‘fairly’ often from downloading content by the content owner’s insistence on data capture. There were geographical differences here too: 22% of UK buyers said they were discouraged ‘very’ often, compared to 10-12% in Germany, France and Belgium.
If you would like to download the free Base One research, you can find the report at: www.b2bmarketing.net/buyersphere11.
What are your conclusions from this interesting report?










You’re in marketing for one reason: Grow.
Grow your company, reputation, customers, impact, profits. Grow yourself. This is a community that will help. It will stretch your mind, connect you to fascinating people, and provide some fun along the way. I am so glad you’re here.
-Mark Schaefer

