Social media feedback as customer prophecy
Jul 24th
My wife and I decided to celebrate for no particular reason at a favorite restaurant. When my wife went to the restroom, I checked-in on Foursquare to pass the time. When I “checked in” to this location, I was surprised and delighted to see a review from one of my best friends pop up on my screen. What a coincidence. He had been to the same restaurant within the same week. Here was his review:
“This restaurant has always been a family favorite but the service has really gone downhill. I’m convinced the management and staff don’t even care any more.”
Wow.
My friend is a very kind and patient man, so the service must have been absolutely horrible for him to leave a review like that!
My wife returned to the table and after 10 minutes we still didn’t have anybody take our drink order. Normally, I would have been engaging in conversation and probably not even notice this delay but now my Spidey Senses seemed to be tingling and tuned to the service level.
It occurred to me that I was now EXPECTING poor service because of my friend’s review. The review had the potential of becoming a self-fulfilling prophecy. Whether we had a good waiter or not, I was now closely watching for signs of problems.
“Don’t you think the service here is slow tonight?” I asked. “I would really like to order a beer.”
“Well, maybe,” my wife responded. “But I’ve noticed that the waiter had a lot of tables getting their food at the same time, so I think this is probably normal.”
She had not received the same influential message that I had, and so had a totally different experience with the restaurant. She was looking forward to a nice meal at a bustling restaurant. I was looking forward to slow service.
This is how the power of online customer feedback can work for or against a business at any given moment. I had not seen my friend or spoken to him about the restaurant. Yet his power of influence was now extending beyond space and time, to me and who knows how many others? This is a new kind of “conversation,” isn’t it? Asynchronous, permanent, searchable … and powerful!
I think this also speaks to the role of social media as a rapid catalyst for change, service, and continuous improvement.
If the restaurant had been attentive to my friend in the first place, they never would have received that negative review. It’s possible that they don’t even know the review exists. And if they don’t address any core problems they’re experiencing, the reviews will continue to pile up to the point that they won’t know what hit them.
Social media is like a Darwinian catalyst. Businesses better adapt, adopt and become the “fittest” because the societal pressures through self-publishing and reviews like this is unprecedented and unrelenting.
With the emerging ubiquity of smart phones, the Internet surrounds us. If I had seen the review before I entered the restaurant, maybe I would have avoided it altogether.
How are you and your customers handling negative reviews? How would you correct this situation if you were the restaurant I visited?
Social media marketing progress in a developing country
Jun 19th
If you can’t see this video, please click here: Mark Schaefer interviews Kimmo Linkama.
On my recent vacation I was able to visit with marketer Kimmo Linkama from Estonia. I was totally impressed with this small country and how it has emerged from decades of Soviet oppression to become a vibrant regional economic engine. The capital of Tallinn is also an extremely beautiful city with much of its Medieval city center in place.
Kimmo hs been a Twitter friend for two years and a valuable member of the {grow} community. This short video discussion is an opportunity to get to know him and see what it’s like working in a country still recovering from decades of communist oppression. How do you establish a social media voice in a small country, with a minor language (Estonian), and well behind the social media marketing curve? I love learning about other views and angles on the social media scene and I think you’ll agree this is a rare and interesting perspective, especially his observation on the seemingly “frantic” activity in America.
The 7 Dwarves Present 7 Silly Social Media Myths
Jun 8th
A {grow} Community Week Contribution by Marjorie Clayman
Once you have been around the blogosphere and Twitter for awhile, you look back on your early days in the online space much like you probably look back on childhood. “Remember when I thought the tooth fairy was real” “Remember when I thought a cookie would make me feel better?”
There are a lot of Social Media myths that I’ve uncovered over the last year or so, and I thought that seven gentlemen from your childhood could do a much better job of presenting these myths than I ever could. So without further delay, the 7 Dwarves present 7 Silly Social Media Myths.
Sneezy: Sneezy wishes to combat the myth that people are always interested in every detail about, well, you. The fact is that most people are in the online world because they have an objective, and for most folks, hearing about every sneeze in your life doesn’t help them along. Some personal details are good, but reporting every event in vivid and graphic detail is something you learn to avoid pretty quickly.
Sleepy: Sleepy would like to tell you that Social Media is not something that is so easy you can do it in your sleep. In fact, that idea that Twitter is really just a place to talk about what you ate for dinner is not nearly the whole story. Social Media actually takes a lot of planning, time, and hard work.
Dopey: Dopey wants to impart to you that the myth that you can say whatever you want online is not true. If you badmouth your client, your boss, or your mother-in-law, you are playing with fire, and it’s a darned silly thing to do. In a time when potential and existing employers are coming through social platforms to see what you’re up to, a little censorship can be a bosom buddy.
Doc: Doc has a big problem with the myth that anyone can be an expert online. He points out that he is called doc because he is a certified doctor. Unless you truly are a: jedi, ninja, expert, boss, top banana, or any other such term, you should probably not include those words in your Twitter profile. In fact, even if you are a complete and total ninja, Doc suggests not broadcasting this belief. It makes you look kind of dopey.
Happy: Although he’s an optimistic kind of guy, Happy said he wanted to talk about the fact that not everyone will become a millionaire just because they tweet a lot. In fact, a lot of the millionaires on Twitter were successful long before that little bird started tweeting. Have reasonable objectives and you’re more likely to be, er, content.
Bashful: The myth that people will naturally gravitate to your blog, your Twitter account, or your anything else online is a myth that needs to be shed rather quickly if you want to succeed online. You can’t be a wallflower if you want to achieve your goals. You have to get out there and mix it up, no matter who you are.
Grumpy: Finally, there’s Grumpy. Grumpy is taking this moment to say that focusing on controversy, cuss words, and harsh criticism is not the best way to get attention online. It might work for a short period of time, but it’s not a way to encourage people to commit to you over the long haul. Just because Grumpy got famous for his grumpiness doesn’t mean just anyone can.
So there you have it. Seven myths about Social Media dispelled fully by the 7 Dwarves. Did they miss anything?
I’d love to hear your thoughts!
Margie Clayman is the 3rd generation at her family’s marketing firm, Clayman Advertising (www.clayad.com) and is the resident blogger at margieclayman.com (www.margieclayman.com).
Case study: How 20 high school students ignited a social media success
Jun 7th
Now here is a neat trick. Precisely as your read this exciting guest post from the brilliant Jon Buscall, I will be meeting him for the first time in Stockholm, Sweden. Jon has become one of my oldest and dearest Twitter friends so the timing of this post is only fitting. Enjoy! ~ Mark
This is a story to inspire even the grumpiest social media naysayer.
If a group of 20 senior high school students can get their heads around social media marketing in the space of a couple of weeks, contribute to a marketing strategy, and help slash an annual marketing budget by over 70 percent whilst delivering improved results, just think what you could do if you let your people loose to explore their own creativity!
The Backstory
Back in 2009 my company started running the marketing campaign for a local Stockholm high school. The school’s income is based solely on the $16,000 it receives per annum per student, paid by the local municipality. Faced with declining numbers of kids born sixteen years ago, the market was becoming increasingly competitive with schools vying for students. Marketing costs were escalating as ad agencies sensed there was money to be made but the school wanted to invest more in facilities for existing students rather than lining marketers’ pockets.
After I met with the school management team and grasped their unique selling point of an academic education in English, I set about persuading the school to launch a daily blog, a Facebook Page and to get on Twitter ASAP.
For that academic year I personally handled the account, ghost blogging and tweeting on a daily basis. My favorite anecdote from that year has to be the student I connected with on Twitter who ended up joining the school. Not bad, eh? $16,000 for a single tweet!
Well, obviously it was more than a tweet, but you get the point! The student visited the school and talked to students and staff after we connected online. But the point is a tweet alerted her to the possibilities found at the school.
Within a year applications to the school were up, marketing costs were down considerably and everything, as the saying goes, was pretty much peachy creamy.
The competition responds
By the start of the next academic year every school in Stockholm seemed to have a blog, a Facebook Page, a Twitter account and a lavish video made by a local ad agency. All the schools — and their ad agencies were following our lead and jumping on the bandwagon. It represented a new revenue stream for the agencies of course. Two months later I would see one school giving away badges with the familiar Facebook “Like” icon on at the annual Stockholm schools recruitment fair.
With the market increasingly competitive and the school looking to invest in books and the building rather than even more marketing, we looked at different solutions. In the end, having spent a decade as a full-time university lecturer I decided to accept the school’s offer to run a Communications class this academic year with the brief to get students involved in the social media campaign. Essentially, they were to be my team of marketing interns.
… and the students take over!
I jumped at the chance to experience what 18-19 year olds were up to, but I quickly discovered they didn’t have a clue about brand personas, integrated marketing campaigns, business blogs or the power of Facebook as a marketing tool. So we started out listening to an array of internet marketing podcasts, reading business blogs and immersing ourselves in content marketing and social media strategy.
Sure, the students’ first blog posts and ventures into podcasting weren’t spectacular but very quickly they were producing material that could be published and included in the school’s online presence. Seizing on this I set up a project where they were required to produce material ahead of the first of three annual Open Houses that are the school’s key recruitment events.
Equipped with cameras, digital recorders and a sense of enthusiasm that I personally find hard to muster when it comes to trying to get people to talk on camera, off they went.
The results were spectacular:
- The video at the top of the article was viewed more than 7,000 times — 5,000 times the week right before Open House!
- Another garnered over 3,000 viewers.
The students promoted their efforts across their social media profiles and I chipped in with a bit of blogging on the school website.
We watched and waited with baited breath to see our results.
It’s All About Creativity & the Network
A rough poll taken in the class showed that on average each student had 450 Facebook “friends”. No wonder word of mouth spread quickly. Teens aren’t just connected to teens their age. Brothers and sisters, relatives and so on, follow each other’s Walls.
And we seeing BIG results. On an extremely cold January evening just after Christmas over 700 prospective students came along to Open House to find out about the school. This was double the figure for the same event the previous year. The school auditorium was so full the principal had to give her introductory welcome speech a second time.
Having grasped the value of showing and not just telling, the students recorded this event to show prospective students ahead of the April Open House just what it’s like to visit the school.
Applications to the school doubled this year and the grade-point average for applicants is considerably higher than last year. Sure, some of this has to do with the commitment of the staff and school management, as well as the efforts of my company to help them along; however, 20 communications students are responsible for a massive portion of this success.
I’m in awe of what they’ve helped the school achieve.
A Few Observations by the Old Guy
I understand how marketing works and I think I have a pretty good understanding of social media. Sharing these skills seemed to set off a spark in these teens and they jumped onboard the social media train with enthusiam rarely seen in a company environment where people are PAID to be enthusiastic!
With passion and dedication they created content that didn’t just impress me, it made me sit up and really take notice. It also struck a chord with their peers, who to judge by the numbers preferred the school’s low-fi 2 minute videos to the glossy 5 minute clips other schools had invested in.
To the students’ credit, the results of this “experiment” were so much better than I dared imagine that the principal has asked me to come back and run the same course with another group in the fall.
Thinking about it now I can see that the experience has taught me an important lesson that all of us working in business should remember: if you can inspire your employees to become an active part of your social media marketing campaign you can reach new goals.
These kids were extremely busy just like your employees, juggling lots of tasks throughout the year. However with a bit of planning (thanks Basecamp!) and training they were able to create content and execute the strategy we’d discussed.
Transfer that kind of approach to your software company, your airline, your food store, your agency or corporation and you can see the possibilities. Just as my students proudly shared their efforts with their network, so will your people help your business reach new people.
Getting the social media content creation out of the hands of your professional marketers and into the hands of the people actually doing the job in your business will have far reaching benefits.
These students were not just involved. They were IGNITED. What are the implications for your own business?
Jon Buscall <http://www.twitter.com/jonbuscall> runs Stockholm-based digital communications agency Jontus Media. He blogs at www.jontusmedia.com/blog Oh, and he has five <http://www.bassethounds.nu>basset hounds!







You’re in marketing for one reason: Grow.
Grow your company, reputation, customers, impact, profits. Grow yourself. This is a community that will help. It will stretch your mind, connect you to fascinating people, and provide some fun along the way. I am so glad you’re here.
-Mark Schaefer










Social Media best practices