Six hot trends in social influence marketing
Aug 5th
Now that access to the high-speed Internet and free social media publishing tools are widespread, everyone can create their own content and have a voice about topics they love. The ability to create powerful content that moves through an audience is a legitimate source of influence on the web, and something that just could have happened now. Influence has been democratized!
Companies like Klout, Kred, PeerIndex, and Appinions are tapping into this powerful new trend and attempting to quantify this new source of influence — not ALL influence, but a very small, important sliver of it — Can people effectively create content that moves through the Internet and elicit a reaction (like a RT, a comment, or opening a link). This is another way of saying, “Who creates buzz?”
While assigning influence to celebrities and sports stars has been common for decades (E scores and Q scores), assigning some measure of word-of-mouth power to the masses opens up some revolutionary possibilities. As I describe in my book Return On Influence, these social scoring systems are still in the silent movie stages but the trend is significant and rapidly moving ahead.
This begs the question … Now what? What do we do with these influencers once we’ve found them? Where is the social scoring trend heading? Here are six developments to watch for in the next phase of this fascinating marketing trend:
1) Moving out of the lab
I recently met with Azeem Azhar, the very bright and ambitious founder of PeerIndex and he noted that in 2012, social influence marketing and outreach programs are moving out of the “experimental stage” and into mainstream marketing budgets.
Frankly some of the early marketing efforts have stumbled out of the gate but companies are finding many creative ways to incorporate these algorithms in ways that find new customers and reward passionate brand advocates. This is being recognized as an entirely fresh marketing channel that will require its own research, measurement, and best practices.
2) Moving into the streets
One of the most significant development in this field in the past few months is Klout’s introduction of a mobile application. The current version is crude, but it is the first step toward making influence rewards ubiquitous.
Eventually apps like this will be able to push alerts to you when you are near any business that is interested in connecting with you and your power of personal influence. So, you can walk off a plane and receive deals, upgrades and special perks wherever you are — no check-ins, no emails, no need to opt-in to a deal.
So far, these “perk” programs have usually been limited to national companies and brands but this innovation will open the floodgate for small and local businesses.
3) Developing the channel
One of the healthiest developments is the number of blog posts I have been seeing that move the conversation from “is social influence real?” to “how do we develop this as a competency?”
Jay Baer recently pushed the discussion forward by challenging readers to better define influencers versus advocates. Chris Brogan wrote an interesting post from the influencer’s viewpoint of advocacy versus selling out. Appinions just released a report called “Why reaching out to Mommy Bloggers is a Broken Model” which is a sign that this conversation is moving forward beyond blanket mailings to anyone on an influencer list.
Now that we have found these influencers, what do we do about it? What new skills and techniques do we use to connect and nurture these powerful word of mouth influencers without being annoying? We need to recognize that even passionate advocates may not know how to best support your cause. How do we teach them to ignite our content? And how do we define influencers, advocates and friends and how do we relate to them differently?
4) Connecting online conversations to offline buying behavior
Many critics contend that online influence does not necessarily translate to offline buying behavior — but these dots are being connected very quickly. In fact, it’s already happening.
Smart phones are going to auto-publish content to your Facebook timeline and other platforms — where we are shopping, what we are listening to, what we are viewing. So it’s a simple matter of connecting your conversations with influencers to these actions.
For example, let’s say you love to post about your favorite music. These algorithms will be able to pick up when your friends add music purchases to their timeline that correspond to your recommendations. More and more search results are including recommendations from your friends, which will also support connections between online and offline behaviors. Over time, an actual dollar value will be assigned to your “influence power.”
5) Influence in context
Social scoring is rapidly moving beyond the Twitter-centric days of just a year ago. For example, Appinions, is leveraging 10 years of Cornell University research to plow through 4.5 million content sources for influencer clues. Instead of just tallying “mentions,” Appinions is using unique semantic software to put the influence data in the context of positive and negative sentiment. This is a sign of the future of social influence marketing — broad capabilities, powerful data-mining, specific market insight.
6) Internal uses of social influence measures
Nearly every social media pundit at sometime or another has pontificated about “the social business” that unleashes employee power in a way that creates many individual beacons shining for the company or brand. If they’re serious about this, why not use these social scoring measures to benchmark the efforts?
I recently wrote about a global consulting company using Kred scores to determine which employees are most effectively representing the company on the web. The results were surprising! Salesforce.com is also identifying and rewarding their “Chatterati” — employees who are the most helpful online influencers, regardless of their title or job role. This is really an enlightened and promising view of the emerging importance and recognition of online influence.
Those are a few tends on my radar screen. What are you seeing out there? Are you exploring practical applications of social influence and influencer outreach?
Klout scores feed a social media sickness
Jun 12th
A couple of weeks ago, I was the keynote speaker before a jammed conference room of 300 people and here is how I was introduced:
“I’d like you to welcome our special guest Mark Schaefer, who has over 40,000 followers on Twitter and a Klout score of 71!”
He made no mention that I have written two books, teach at a university, have 30 years of international marketing experience or that I have two masters degrees. He probably doesn’t even know or care that I have raised two great children, am a devoted husband and contribute time to charities and mentoring.
Is Klout more important than life?
It drives home a critical point though. “Social proof” like Twitter followers, Facebook Likes and Klout scores are exceedingly important on the Internet. In fact, as I explain in Return On Influence, as people look for short-cuts to truth in our information-dense digital world, these numbers may be even more important than what we actually accomplish in our lives. That’s hard to say, let alone accept, but it’s true.
Little wonder that a subculture has arisen on the web determined to achieve this social proof by any means necessary.
This group is dedicated to gaming their influence scores because they see this as a true reflection of their personal worth. There is even an online commodity market that buys and sells +K’s on Klout in some quixotic quest for self-worth.
A hit to the ego
After another recent Klout algorithmic change, many people’s numbers slipped again over the past two weeks. Instead of looking at this as simply a tweak in a business model, many people took this as a personal affront, a blast to their very being. Here is a post from a friend after his Klout slipped day by day for 26 days:
26 CYBER ATTACKS ON MY SELF ESTEEM AND WELL BEING WITH ONLY ONE BACKSLAP IN THE MIDDLE TO ALLEVIATE THE PAIN AND SHAME. ITS A SCHOOL OF HARD KNOCKS…
Another guy chimed in complaining that his Klout score slipped when he had to actually pay attention to client work for a couple of weeks.
A young man who works night and day to game his numbers asked me how he can turn his growing social capital into a career. I told him that he can’t … and encouraged him to learn a skill that will actually help people.
Let’s keep focused on business benefits
Social scoring is an important new business trend and it’s important to understand what companies like Klout and Appinions are up to. We have always known that there are certain powerful word-of-mouth influencers out there but finding them has been out of reach for all but the biggest and richest companies. We are on the brink of a truly revolutionary ability to accurately identify, connect with, and reward authentic brand advocates throughout the world we never knew existed. We’ll even be able to place a dollar value (yes — a return on investment!) on powerful individual word of mouth influencers, and in fact that is already happening. If you’re in marketing, you undoubtedly need to understand this trend!
But I am disturbed by this parallel consequence of people obsessing with a number as a legitimacy of their human worth. I know there is nothing I can do about that, but I’m not going to contribute to it either. I’ve been asked by my publisher to write a short book on how to increase your Klout score. It would be an easy financial windfall that would build on my previous work. But it simply flies in the face of my principles and encourages behaviors that will hurt people in the end in my opinion.
Checking out Klout, Kred, Peer Index and Empire Avenue values can be entertaining but anybody truly enslaved to these numbers for their self-esteem needs a reality check. And here is the irony. All these folks eventually will be sniffed out as fakes, which will really crush their self-esteem. In the end, true authority, expertise, and kindness will win out.
Want to REALLY increase your social influence? Here’s how.
Surround yourself with people who care about you.
Do good work.
Be kind and helpful.
Just do those three things and the influence — the influence that matters — will take care of itself. OK?
Getting your first book published: Lessons learned!
May 29th
Do you dream of writing and publishing a book some day? It was always something I’ve wanted to do and I was so fortunate to have the opportunity to do it this year. Here are some lessons that you might find helpful from my journey with Return On Influence.
How did I get a book contract?
I was in an unusual position. Beginning in 2010, publishers actually sought me out to write a book. Why? I think there were three things that boosted me into that position:
1) I had demonstrated my writing ability through my blog
2) I had successfully self-published my first book, The Tao of Twitter (a great stepping stone!)
3) I had an engaged community who would be advocates for the book
I think this last part is particularly important. Like any content on the web, you have to be able to “ignite” it for it to be useful. Even if I had written the world’s greatest book, it would never sell if I couldn’t light the match. Establishing a blog or Facebook community seems like a good first-step for publishing today.
The good news is, these opportunities are available to anybody today to get them into a position to get a publishing contract. The bad news is, it takes a LOT of work to get there.
How did I choose a publisher?
After meeting with several publishers, I developed a good personal chemistry with the people at McGraw Hill. They really respect and support their authors. It ended up being a great decision.
When I turned in my proposal, it ended like this — “I really don’t know what this book is going to be about because the topic is entirely new. I don’t know what I will find and I have to let the research determine the outcome of the book.” They let me write it any way, which I think is cool. And the book ended up being 80% different than the original proposal!
How did I choose a topic?
There was no master plan, really. The emerging marketing trend of social influence was simply something I was interested in — Is there anything to this Klout stuff? How does power show up on the web? Why are companies scrambling to implement these Klout Perks?
If I was going to devote months of my life to a project, first and foremost, it had to be interesting!
I also realized that I had to write a book that had not been written before — something COMPLETELY different. Choosing this topic of social influence was a big risk. When I started the project, nobody had heard of Klout or social scoring — the trend was just emerging — but I thought this was going to go mainstream and I was right, thankfully.
What was the writing process?
The biggest challenge for me and other writers I have talked to is blocking out the chunks of time necessary to get the project done. A project this size cannot be accomplished with an hour here and there. Even when I reserved a whole week to write, I looked up at 9 p.m. on a Thursday night and not written a word — my week had been filled solving client problems. This was a panicky moment. How was I going to get this done?
So I blocked out another week and made a decision I have never made before or since — I was going to write, even if it meant disappointing customers. That’s gut-wrenching and wrong but I had to do it.
My wife helped me as a research assistant and also transcribed about 50 taped interviews. From start to finish it took about nine months to research and write the book, with about three solid months of intense writing and re-writing.
Editing and promotion
I completely under-estimated the time required AFTER the book was written. The manuscript went through four editing phases. Although the final product is probably 95% the same as what I first turned in, there were a lot of decisions about the title, the tone and direction of the book. McGraw-Hill wanted it to be a “how-to” book and that just didn’t align with my vision. They let me follow my own path, but all these discussions took a lot of time.
Once the book launched, I was doing 2-4 interviews a day for eight weeks. This time, I warned my customers ahead of time and I was able to put off some projects to allow enough time to properly promote the book. I took a financial hit but I realized that this was a once in a lifetime opportunity and I needed to go for it.
Did I make money from the book?
I knew going into it that the goal for this book was to expand my reach and reputation, not become rich from book sales. So I approached it realistically. Even though I received a generous payment upfront and the book is selling very well, on a per-hour basis, this would have been a bad economic decision.
However, I am already receiving the benefits of being a published author through new invitations to speak and consult. In that regard, I forecast that there will be a long-term financial benefit.
What’s next?
I feel really proud about where I am right now with Return On Influence. I proved to myself that I could do it and the publisher is happy with a best-selling book (the first printing sold out in eight weeks). My community and the reviewers have embraced the book.
I do have a few ideas for a new book but the scope of these ambitious projects is quite daunting because of the time it would take to pull it off. It will be a difficult decision to make but you can be assured that if I write a new book it will also be “out there.”
In the near-term, I’m happy to announce that McGraw-Hill bought the worldwide rights to The Tao of Twitter and a new edition with about 30 percent new content will be available by the end of the year.
So those are the highlights.
What other questions do you have that I can answer for you? Was this helpful?
PeerIndex Founder reveals social marketing developments
Apr 24th
Click here is you can;t see this video interview with Azeem Azhar, founder of PeerIndex.
I had a chance to catch up with PeerIndex founder Azeem Azhar at his homebase in London. Azeem is prominently featured Return On Influence and this was a golden opportunity to catch up with him about some of the newest developments. In this interview we cover:
Is social scoring getting traction? Is it creating measurable value for companies and brands or is it still experimental?
How is the company going to use its new round of funding?
Why is social scoring so disruptive for many traditional advertising agencies?
How are companies realizing “TV ad-like” results by approaching influencers?
What is the “magic middle” of influencer outreach?
Is this still experimental or are companies beginning to dedicate real money towards influence marketing?
How are companies measuring benefits from this new channel?
I think you’ll find this conversation quite interesting!









You’re in marketing for one reason: Grow.
Grow your company, reputation, customers, impact, profits. Grow yourself. This is a community that will help. It will stretch your mind, connect you to fascinating people, and provide some fun along the way. I am so glad you’re here.
-Mark Schaefer

