Posts tagged Twitter strategy
20,000 Followers. Now What?
Feb 24th
There is no playbook for Twitter. I’m learning as I go, just like you, and I’ve tried to share my ups and downs along the way.
I’ve written about the spirituality of the social web, the social media time crunch, and my anxiety about the velocity of change and my own social media overload.
One year ago, I wrote a post called 8,000 Followers. Now What? Since that time, I have gained 12,000 new followers … so a lot has changed! I don’t often write about myself but it seems to connect with people when I share my experiences, so here’s what it’s like to have 20,000 followers on Twitter.
Where did all these people come from?
As {grow} continues to … well, grow, I’ve been blessed with many new readers from every corner of the world. This has directly translated into Twitter followers — about 1,000 per month and accelerating. I haven’t had any specific plan to gain followers, it has come in an organic way. If you follow me, or I see that you tweet about {grow}, I will generally follow you back.
Not only do I have a lot of followers, I have a lot of ENGAGED followers because I have aggressively culled spammers from the beginning. So my tribe is legitimate and my tribe is awesome!
One question I’m often asked is, why do I follow so many people back … what good can possibly come from it? Actually, a lot! I discuss this at length in my book The Tao of Twitter, but the short answer is this: Think of Twitter followers as atoms bumping around in a test tube. The more atoms there are (as long as they are relevant to your business) the better the chance for a reaction — a business benefit! The catalyst for that reaction is engagement through meaningful content, and the relationship is sustained through authentic helpfulness.
Business benefits of Twitter
I’m a blogger but I also teach and run a business. Why do I spend so much time with Twitter? Because it flat-out delivers the goods! Here are a few real business benefits I realized DIRECTLY from Twitter connections in the past 12 months:
- Invited to teach at Rutgers University.
- Awarded an engagement to be the social media consultant for the UK consulate in New York.
- Enabled the dozens of connections that created Social Slam, one of the premier social media events of the year (you’re coming, right?).
- Acquired my three largest customers.
I could easily write 100 more business benefit bullets. I have been very fortunate, but I see this same kind of success happening repeatedly for many friends and students. Here’s the best part of all – I’ve developed deep, meaningful relationships that will last a lifetime. Not just Facebook-style “friends.” Friends you would have over to dinner!
It is poetic and sublime that my 20,000th follower has the last name of Gandhi. You can’t make this stuff up.
What about the wall of noise?
When I wrote my last Twitter update a year ago, I was creeped out by this growing number of people following me. How would I cut through the noise?
To be honest, it hasn’t been that bad. Yes, Twitter is mostly noise even if you do a good job culling the spam. But I realized I had neither the obligation nor the patience to engage with a crowd that large. However, I DO engage with anybody who makes an effort to engage with me. I manage this primarily through lists, which I view on Hootsuite or Seesmic. I’m at peace knowing that I can’t be on top of everything and respond to everybody as I would like. I know that sometimes messages are going to slip through the cracks. I just have to do my best and hope people are gracious.
Another trend I’ve noticed is that some connections last forever but others come and go in waves. People will connect for awhile and then I won’t hear from them for a few months. So it’s more like waves of people lapping at my beach, not a tsunami knocking me over!
The economy of favors
One advantage of a large number of highly-engaged followers is that I can tweet stuff out for people and topics I believe in and sometimes it makes a difference. It’s nice to be in a position to help wonderful people.
I receive requests for favors about every hour of the day. I’m glad to help, with one exception — When I have no idea who you are! That makes it kind of awkward. I think sometimes people feel they know me through the blog but if you have never showed up through comments or tweets, I probably don’t know you’re out there. I “tithe” at least 10 percent of my time each week to help people in the {grow} community through phone calls, emails and other forms of free consulting. I enjoy this … but let me know you exist first : ) If you make an effort to connect, I seldom refuse a request for help!
How many followers is enough?
The answer is different for every person. If you run a beauty salon in New York, having followers from Australia probably won’t help you. Nurturing targeted followers from your area is probably all you need to concentrate on. But if your potential market is the world, then why not nurture contacts from all over? So it all depends.
According to statistics in an interesting post in Tom Webster’s wonderful Brand Savant blog, I would be in the top one-half percent of Twitter users with this follower base of 20,000. That doesn’t mean squat. I know my place in the world, and here it is — Twitter doesn’t affect my marriage, my kids, or my friends. To the extent that it helps my business and my students, that is a plus.
What about Klout?
Since last year this little topic called social influence has started to make waves. It’s easy to get knocked off center when somebody is making a report card about you. I like to compete in business and in sports but I think paying too much attention to Klout will be destructive. My Klout score was 76 at one point and the other day somebody said it was a 71. I had to admit that just for a moment, I felt competitive about that! But that is going to drive the WRONG behaviors in me and others. So I am blocking that stuff out and focusing on what I love — creating insanely great content, connecting with amazing people no matter what their “score” is, and being helpful.
What’s next?
Obviously you can’t plan for something like 20,000 people showing up on your virtual doorstep. I think that I liked Twitter best when I had about 400 followers. But when somebody follows me, I consider it an honor and I’m not going to disrespect that, especially with all the proven benefits that have occurred. So, come on in. We’ll be in this together and I’ll figure out a way to handle it.
Well, that’s my 2011 Twitter progress report. What successes and frustrations are you experiencing with Twitter, and how can I help?
Illustration: National Geographic
Social scoring and the business case for blocking Twitter spammers
Dec 27th
Judging by her school-issue personal photo, Twana Florance appears to be a mild-mannered, middle-aged matron from Twin Falls, Idaho. But there is no Twana Florance. Twana is probably some teenager in a Third World country hired to propagate and populate fake Twitter accounts that will later be sold on eBay.
Twitter has done a good job clearing out most of the porn stars and MLM hacks who almost brought the service to its knees by mid-2009. But the new breed of spammer is hiding behind a tender smile like Twana.
For the time being, it’s the stupid tweets that give it away but the spammers will probably get around that soon too. What does it hurt? What does it matter if spammers trick you into following them? Believe it or not, blocking spammers like “Twana” might actually lead to important business benefits in the future. Here’s why.
Social influence and spam
A few months ago my friend Steve Dodd made an interesting observation. Chris Brogan, one of the top five social media bloggers in the world who currently carries enough Twitter followers to form a small nation, tweeted out about a specific issue … and I did too. Steve — who has a great analytical mind — noticed that my message, sent out at the same time, was re-tweeted about the same number of times as Chris. However, the number of RT’s compared to my number of followers was a vastly larger ratio compared to Chris.
“If a higher percentage of people re-tweet your message, wouldn’t this indicate that you are more influential than Chris?” Steve asked.
At first I dismissed this as a mildly-interesting aberration but the more I thought about it, the more I think Steve might be on to something.
One of the reasons Chris has so many followers is that he typically doesn’t block any one. Chris stated at a speech I attended last year that “half the people who follow me are spammers and porn stars.”
In the old days (six months ago) of social influence, having a large number of followers — no matter who they are — was a status symbol. But in this age of algorithms and Klout scores, simply having large numbers of non-human followers could work against you because that “conversation ratio” is going to be a measure of influence.
Here is what the new social scoring systems are reflecting: Spammers don’t engage. Spammer don’t re-tweet. Having spammers among your list of followers will drive your social influence score DOWN.
Ethics of blocking spam
From the beginning, I have done my best to look at the profile of every person who follows me to determine whether I should follow back, just let them follow me, or if I should nuke them. I probably block about 25 percent of the people who try to follow me because I attract a lot of crap I guess! Yes, this takes a little extra work, but the 18,000 people who follow me are legitimate, real people to the best of my knowledge.
When I adopted this strategy, I didn’t have social scoring systems like Klout in mind. Ejecting spammers was just the right thing to do (and still is) for four reasons:
- My Twitter Tribe matters. If I follow you, I choose to do so. No auto-follows, ever. Before I follow, I have read your bio, some of your tweets and probably clicked your link. I have a quality audience and it’s staying that way.
- I want an audience to be proud of. This probably sounds old-fashioned but I don’t want to do anything in my life that I wouldn’t be proud to disclose to my children. And if they examined my Twitter audience, I would not want them to see a bunch of nymphs peddling their videos. Anybody can see who you’re following. What does your audience say about you?
- I want to protect you. If I block the spamaholics I keep them from my tweets and I keep them, in a small way, from you. I see so many of these folks who copy “Follow Friday” lists trying to lure followers. No. Stay away from my friends dammit.
- Because I just do not want to play that game. I’m not going to be passive and imply that what they’re doing is OK.
The business case for blocking
Blocking sends a message and that’s important. But I increasingly believe that having a quality list of followers who actually exist and care about you is going to make a difference because measures of social scoring are going to be a big deal. I recently wrote about the importance of Klout scores and other systems that will emerge. If you missed it, please read it because it’s an important trend that is even having an impact on SEO strategies.
And by the way, Chris (with 167,350 followers) has a Klout score of 84.
Me? I currently have just 10 percent of the followers Chris has but have a Klout score of 76. My hypothesis is that the quality of my followers is one contributor since I do not pretend for a minute to have the reach or power of Chris Brogan.
I don’t want to turn this into a debate about Klout or its social scoring competitors. Whether you or I philosophically agree with what they do is irrelevant because these systems exist, are growing in importance, and we need to deal with this fact dispassionately.
My point is that there might be a legitimate business case to support a strategy of blocking spammers, as well as an ethical one. What’s your take on it? Does this make sense to you?

Take the Mystery Out of Twitter!
Click on the image for a Special Amazon promotion!








You’re in marketing for one reason: Grow.
Grow your company, reputation, customers, impact, profits. Grow yourself. This is a community that will help. It will stretch your mind, connect you to fascinating people, and provide some fun along the way. I am so glad you’re here.
-Mark Schaefer

